More Scrumptious Schumann

Although I have always considered Robert Schumann an uneven composer, there are some works that really grab me. A favorite work – and I mean across all composers – is his song cycle Dichterliebe. I have two recordings of this, and have considered getting a third. None of his other works have had quite the same impact until I ran into Davidsbündlertänze.

This is the positive side of an infatuation with a particular performer, in this case Paolo Giacometti: exploring literature I have passed by. Giacometti's latest recording is on a modern piano. Up until now, I have known him as a "specialist" in period instruments of the 19th century. There is no reason to pigeonhole him. It seems like each recording of his I get is better than the last.

His latest recording has drawn very positive reviews. It should. Giacometti brings warmth to his performance without being sappy. He has just the right amount of romanticism to bring out the best in Schumann. His touch is exquisite. The recording quality is superb; it is a SACD and it would be interesting to hear this on an appropriate surround system, just to see if the sound could possibly be better.

Only three years passed between composition of Davidsbündlertänze and Dichterliebe. I feel the connection. Both are comprised of miniatures, but they seem to fit together as a whole. Schumann at his best.

I wonder what recording project Giacometti will take on next. He has risen to status of "favorite artist" – whatever he records, I'm sure I'll buy it.